{
  "url": "https://www.moonstonehq.com/articles/are-damaged-pokemon-cards-worth-anything",
  "slug": "are-damaged-pokemon-cards-worth-anything",
  "title": "Are Damaged Pokémon Cards Worth Anything? 78.7% Carry a Price, at a Median 39.7% of Mint",
  "summary": "Our snapshot covers 21,364 English products carrying a Near Mint quote, read on October 9, 2026, though our source observes each condition on its own schedule. A damaged copy carries its own quoted price on 78.7% of them, at a median 39.7% of the Near Mint price, which the trade shortens to mint. A rung is one step of a card's condition ladder, meaning the price published for a single condition. The middle half of the damaged rungs runs from 25.3% to 58.1% of mint, so the half-price rule of thumb fits about one card in four, and below twenty cents the damaged rung is missing about two times in three.",
  "section": "Buyer's Guide",
  "published": "2026-10-10",
  "readMinutes": 16,
  "publisher": "moonstone",
  "findings": [
    {
      "value": "78.7%",
      "measures": "of English cards carry a damaged quote",
      "basis": "16,824 of 21,364, snapshot read October 9, 2026, each rung on its own observation date"
    },
    {
      "value": "39.7%",
      "measures": "median damaged quote, as a share of Near Mint",
      "basis": "on those 16,824 cards"
    },
    {
      "value": "26.7%",
      "measures": "land in the 40% to 60% band people expect",
      "basis": "4,494 of 16,824"
    },
    {
      "value": "34.1%",
      "measures": "of damaged quotes are no larger than the fee on their own sale",
      "basis": "5,734 of 16,824, on eBay's published fee"
    }
  ],
  "tables": [
    {
      "title": "The damaged quote as a share of Near Mint, and how widely it scatters",
      "columns": [
        "Near Mint price",
        "Damaged quotes",
        "A quarter sit below",
        "Median",
        "A quarter sit above",
        "Inside 40% to 60%"
      ],
      "rows": [
        {
          "Near Mint price": "Under $1",
          "Damaged quotes": "6,750",
          "A quarter sit below": "32.6%",
          "Median": "48.8%",
          "A quarter sit above": "71.1%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "2,029 (30.1%)"
        },
        {
          "Near Mint price": "$1 to $5",
          "Damaged quotes": "4,060",
          "A quarter sit below": "27.3%",
          "Median": "38.9%",
          "A quarter sit above": "54.5%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "1,183 (29.1%)"
        },
        {
          "Near Mint price": "$5 to $20",
          "Damaged quotes": "3,021",
          "A quarter sit below": "21.4%",
          "Median": "34.0%",
          "A quarter sit above": "51.6%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "728 (24.1%)"
        },
        {
          "Near Mint price": "$20 to $100",
          "Damaged quotes": "2,038",
          "A quarter sit below": "20.6%",
          "Median": "30.3%",
          "A quarter sit above": "44.0%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "392 (19.2%)"
        },
        {
          "Near Mint price": "$100 to $500",
          "Damaged quotes": "826",
          "A quarter sit below": "20.2%",
          "Median": "27.6%",
          "A quarter sit above": "39.8%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "143 (17.3%)"
        },
        {
          "Near Mint price": "$500 and up",
          "Damaged quotes": "129",
          "A quarter sit below": "18.6%",
          "Median": "26.3%",
          "A quarter sit above": "38.6%",
          "Inside 40% to 60%": "19 (14.7%)"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Near Mint and damaged on ten English cards, with the day each rung was seen",
      "columns": [
        "Card",
        "Near Mint",
        "Damaged",
        "Damaged share",
        "Rungs observed"
      ],
      "rows": [
        {
          "Card": "[Rayquaza](/card/col1-20), [Call of Legends](/set/call%20of%20legends)",
          "Near Mint": "$1,013.27",
          "Damaged": "$22.14",
          "Damaged share": "2.2%",
          "Rungs observed": "both October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Lugia-EX](/card/bw8-134), [Plasma Storm](/set/plasma%20storm)",
          "Near Mint": "$1,344.24",
          "Damaged": "$211.63",
          "Damaged share": "15.7%",
          "Rungs observed": "both October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Charizard](/card/base1-4), [Base Set](/set/base%20set)",
          "Near Mint": "$928.06",
          "Damaged": "$182.08",
          "Damaged share": "19.6%",
          "Rungs observed": "both October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Umbreon VMAX](/card/swsh7-215), [Evolving Skies](/set/evolving%20skies)",
          "Near Mint": "$2,351.42",
          "Damaged": "$958.50",
          "Damaged share": "40.8%",
          "Rungs observed": "both October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Umbreon ex](/card/sv08.5-161), [Prismatic Evolutions](/set/prismatic%20evolutions)",
          "Near Mint": "$1,301.12",
          "Damaged": "$750.00",
          "Damaged share": "57.6%",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 9, damaged August 6"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Leafeon ex](/card/sv08.5-144), Prismatic Evolutions",
          "Near Mint": "$315.40",
          "Damaged": "$225.00",
          "Damaged share": "71.3%",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 9, damaged September 23"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Victini](/card/sv10.5b-171), [Black Bolt](/set/black%20bolt)",
          "Near Mint": "$627.44",
          "Damaged": "no quote",
          "Damaged share": "not quoted",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Umbreon](/card/neo2-32), [Neo Discovery](/set/neo%20discovery)",
          "Near Mint": "$300.00",
          "Damaged": "no quote",
          "Damaged share": "not quoted",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Glaceon ex](/card/sv08.5-150), Prismatic Evolutions",
          "Near Mint": "$261.54",
          "Damaged": "no quote",
          "Damaged share": "not quoted",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 9"
        },
        {
          "Card": "[Paradise Resort](/card/svp-150), [SVP Black Star Promos](/set/svp%20black%20star%20promos)",
          "Near Mint": "$597.66",
          "Damaged": "no quote",
          "Damaged share": "not quoted",
          "Rungs observed": "mint October 8"
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "charts": [
    {
      "title": "A damaged copy has a quoted price, by what the mint copy costs",
      "unit": "%",
      "note": "Share of English products whose condition ladder carries a Damaged rung. All 21,364 products with a Near Mint quote, snapshot read October 9, 2026, with each rung carrying its own observation date.",
      "points": [
        {
          "label": "Under 10c",
          "value": 26.3,
          "basis": "306 of 1,165"
        },
        {
          "label": "10c to 20c",
          "value": 33.9,
          "basis": "1,000 of 2,954"
        },
        {
          "label": "20c to 30c",
          "value": 61.5,
          "basis": "1,534 of 2,495"
        },
        {
          "label": "30c to 50c",
          "value": 87.8,
          "basis": "1,918 of 2,185"
        },
        {
          "label": "50c to 75c",
          "value": 93.4,
          "basis": "1,197 of 1,282"
        },
        {
          "label": "75c to $1",
          "value": 95.3,
          "basis": "795 of 834"
        },
        {
          "label": "$1 to $5",
          "value": 96.6,
          "basis": "4,060 of 4,205"
        },
        {
          "label": "$5 and up",
          "value": 96.3,
          "basis": "6,014 of 6,244"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "What the selling fee takes out of a damaged sale",
      "unit": "%",
      "note": "Median eBay published final value fee as a share of the damaged quote, by the card's Near Mint price, assuming the card is sold on its own. Under a dollar the fee runs 1.7 times the whole sale. English damaged quotes, counts beside each band, snapshot read October 9, 2026, each rung on its own observation date.",
      "points": [
        {
          "label": "Under $1",
          "value": 171.1,
          "basis": "6,750 quotes"
        },
        {
          "label": "$1 to $5",
          "value": 47.3,
          "basis": "4,060 quotes"
        },
        {
          "label": "$5 to $20",
          "value": 22.6,
          "basis": "3,021 quotes"
        },
        {
          "label": "$20 to $100",
          "value": 16.4,
          "basis": "2,038 quotes"
        },
        {
          "label": "$100 to $500",
          "value": 14,
          "basis": "826 quotes"
        },
        {
          "label": "$500 and up",
          "value": 13.5,
          "basis": "129 quotes"
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "sections": [
    "Where the damaged price runs out",
    "Damage costs proportionally more on a dear card",
    "On a cheap card the selling fee decides the outcome",
    "Four of these ten cards have no damaged quote",
    "A damaged Japanese card usually has no rung to read",
    "What the mint copy is worth decides your next move"
  ],
  "method": [
    "POPULATION, stated first. Our condition_quotes snapshot holds the per-condition ladder for 52,130 marketplace products, 50,043 of which carry a Near Mint rung. Those 50,043 are three different populations and this article is about one of them: 21,364 products that resolve to an English catalogue card, 20,736 that resolve to a Japanese one, and 7,943 that resolve to no catalogue row at all. Every headline figure above is the English 21,364, which is 99.6% of the 21,449 distinct English products in our catalogue. Catalogue rows sharing a marketplace product id are collapsed to one row, preferring the lexically first card id, because 243 English product ids are claimed by two rows each. The pooled 50,043 reads differently and is printed once, in the Japanese section, so the difference stays visible. AS OF. Each rung carries the date our source last observed it, and the rungs are not all read on one schedule. Across all 96,400 English rungs the newest reading is October 9, 2026; 79.6% were observed within seven days of that, 90.7% within thirty, and the oldest is March 24, 2025. At the seven-day cut the damaged rung is the stalest in the ladder, 66.9% against 67.1% for heavily played, and by thirty days the two have swapped, 80.0% damaged against 79.1% heavily played. Only 50.7% of English ladders have every rung observed inside a week. Of the 16,824 damaged and Near Mint pairs behind the 39.7% headline, 5,122 have their two rungs observed more than seven days apart and 3,366 more than thirty, with a worst gap of 485 days. ROBUSTNESS, since that staleness could move the headline. Restricting to the 10,841 cards whose damaged and Near Mint rungs carry the same observation date gives a median share of 38.09% against the 39.69% published above, a gap of 1.6 points, and the same-day figure sits closer to the 36.0% that [Pokémon Card Condition Price Guide](/articles/pokemon-card-condition-price-guide) measured on its own same-day pairs. The headline is quoted on all 16,824 pairs because that's the population a reader looking up one card is drawing from. A ladder is one snapshot, so no figure here measures a change over time. PRICES. Every figure is a listing quote on one marketplace, never a completed sale, and asks run above sales on cheap cards. The snapshot stores one row per product per condition, so each rung holds exactly one quote and there were no duplicates to reconcile. Shares are each card's own rung divided by its own Near Mint quote, then the median of those shares, never a ratio of two medians. Medians take the upper middle value on even samples, and the quarter-below and quarter-above columns are the values a quarter and three quarters of the way up the same sorted list. The 40% to 60% counts are inclusive of both ends and compared in integer cents: 4,494 of 16,824 cards, 26.71%, and per band 2,029, 1,183, 728, 392, 143 and 19. Only 4 of the 16,824 English ladders carry a different printing on the damaged rung than on the Near Mint rung, so printing mismatch moves nothing here. THE ABSENCE. A missing rung means our source published no quote for that condition when the snapshot was read. It can mean nobody has a copy listed in that condition, or that our source did not publish the rung, and we cannot separate those two from inside our own data. Blank rungs are left out of every median and every share-of-mint count; the coverage bars count them only as the gap they are, and no chart enters one as a zero. Price bands are closed on the lower bound and open on the upper, they partition the population with nothing counted twice, and the eight coverage bars sum to 21,364. FEES. eBay's published final value fee for trading cards, 13.25% of the sale plus a per-order 40 cents, or 30 cents at or under $10, from the schedule recorded in our own code and read from eBay's seller fee page on September 23, 2026. The schedule drops to 2.35% on the portion of a sale above $7,500, which no damaged quote here reaches. The per-order charge is applied once per card, because the question is what one damaged card sells for on its own; a lot pays it once for the whole lot, which is the point made above. Postage, packaging, promoted-listing fees and any sales tax are not counted, so the cheap-end figures are generous. THE COHERENCE TEST is the one our own price code applies before publishing a Near Mint figure: a ladder is refused whole when any played rung is priced above the Near Mint rung. 5,837 English ladders fail it. They are counted in the coverage figures, because the question there is whether a quote exists, and they are what the callout above warns about. LINKS. All ten sets named in that table carry a link to their set page. Nothing in this article is financial advice."
  ],
  "terms": "Figures are moonstone's own recorded measurements, dated as published. Quote them with the population stated beside them. The article at `url` is the human form of this file."
}