If you pulled Chansey 187/167 and Bloodmoon Ursaluna ex 216/167 out of the same Twilight Masquerade box, you'd probably sleeve them together and think of them as the same kind of money. On November 21 they nearly were, at $42.19 and $41.42 on TCGplayer's market price. The grading math treats them as strangers. Once PSA's fee and eBay's commission come out, the Chansey beats a straight raw sale by $30.91 on average while the Ursaluna loses to it by $25.37.

It isn't luck of the grade. The Ursaluna gems a little more often than the Chansey does, 44.6% of its submissions against 41.6%, so on odds alone you'd send the bear. What sinks it is how little a perfect copy fetches. A gem-mint Ursaluna trades at $136.50, and the Chansey's goes for $278.18, a premium of 6.6x over its raw price where the Ursaluna gets 3.3x. When the top grade pays that modestly, the fees eat most of it, and a 9 at $45.00 isn't much of a consolation prize for a card that sells for $41.42 as is. One caveat, and it's the only one I'll give: the math scores any copy that misses a 9 as worthless, which flatters the raw sale on every card that loses.

Grade it or keep it raw: the ledger, as of November 21, 2026

CardRawPSA 10PSA 9Gem rateGraded, after feesRaw, less eBay fee
Greninja ex 214/167$223.62$660.00$280.0043.1%$297.38$193.59
Perrin 220/167$130.62$299.00$135.4446.1%$109.88$112.91
Eevee 188/167$71.06$289.99$89.0039.5%$77.76$61.24
Chansey 187/167$42.19$278.18$65.0041.6%$67.11$36.20
Bloodmoon Ursaluna ex 216/167$41.42$136.50$45.0044.6%$10.16$35.53
Carmine 217/167$41.11$141.00$61.5047.8%$20.32$35.26
Sinistcha ex 210/167$33.01$124.00$34.5047.1%$3.15$28.24
Lana's Aid 219/167$27.41$99.43$32.2549.6%$5.92$23.38
Kieran 218/167$24.16$93.83$27.4947.8%$11.58$20.56
Hisuian Growlithe 181/167$22.55$188.45$35.0042.7%$23.72$19.16

The Greninja ex 214/167 is the card I keep coming back to. It shed $73.82 raw over the month, the biggest dollar loss in Twilight Masquerade, and it's still the clearest yes of the ten, with a $660.00 top slab that leaves grading $103.79 ahead. Hisuian Growlithe 181/167 is the odd one. Its gem-mint copies sell at 8.4x raw, the widest gap in the group, and grading still only wins by $4.56, because there isn't much raw value under it to multiply. Then there's Lana's Aid 219/167, the most reliable gem here at 49.6%, which you'd think would make it a natural submission. It finishes $29.30 behind. Perrin 220/167 lands $3.03 short, which is close enough that I wouldn't argue with anyone who sent theirs in. Sinistcha ex 210/167 is the bleakest case on the page. It sells for $33.01 raw, and grading one works out to $3.15 on average, which isn't much of a reward for the wait.

Twilight Masquerade's expensive end lost ground

Most money lost per card

TCGplayer market price, October 23 to November 21, 2026
  1. 1Greninja ex 214/167Greninja ex 214/167$297.44 to $223.62slid steadily; no single day carried more than 16% of the move-24.8%
  2. 2Perrin 220/167Perrin 220/167$151.84 to $130.62slid steadily; no single day carried more than 15% of the move-14.0%
  3. 3Lana's Aid 219/167Lana's Aid 219/167$32.45 to $27.41slid steadily; no single day carried more than 32% of the move-15.5%
  4. 4Hisuian Growlithe 181/167Hisuian Growlithe 181/167$26.12 to $22.55slid steadily; no single day carried more than 28% of the move-13.7%
  5. 5Kieran 218/167Kieran 218/167$27.67 to $24.16slid steadily; no single day carried more than 24% of the move-12.7%

The raw prices underneath all this drifted down, though not across the whole set: the typical card finished flat, and 104 got more expensive against 102 that got cheaper. At the $20-and-up end, 9 of 11 lost value, and a complete binder of the set, one copy per slot, fell 10.5%, from $1,161.51 to $1,039.79. Most of that came from the top. Five cards supplied 75.6% of the losses, and none of them dropped in a single repricing; they leaked. What you give up when you mail a card to PSA is the price you could have sold it for, and on the Greninja that price is $73.82 lower than it was on October 23. A cheaper raw card is a lower bar for the slab. It won't save Kieran 218/167, which fell 12.7% and still comes out at $11.58 graded against $20.56 sold raw.

The Greninja, the Chansey and Eevee 188/167, which clears the raw sale by $16.52, are the three I'd mail. The Growlithe's $4.56 margin is thin enough that the cost of shipping to PSA and back, which the math leaves out, could plausibly swallow it, so I'd leave that one raw and let someone with a bigger submission take the chance. Carmine 217/167 has a respectable 9 at $61.50 and still comes up $14.94 short, and it joins Kieran, Lana's Aid, Sinistcha ex 210/167 and the Ursaluna as binder cards to me, worth more in a penny sleeve than in a slab. That leaves the Chansey and the Ursaluna, worth the same money and sitting on the same binder page, headed to very different places.

Population: Twilight Masquerade, 226 English cards with a TCGplayer market price on both October 23, 2026 and November 21, 2026. Every move compares a card to itself on the same TCGplayer product, first day against last, before anything is ranked or summed; a set total is never compared across days. Prices are TCGplayer market prices for the flagship printing, read from our daily price file. Graded figures are sold medians from our graded comps, PSA population counts come from our daily registry snapshot, and the expected value counts the PSA 9 outcome as well as the PSA 10, net of the grading fee and selling costs. The expected value sits beside the raw price less the same eBay selling fee, so the two compare like with like. It counts copies that grade below a 9 at nothing and leaves out shipping to PSA and back. Angle: whether grading pays: PSA 10 and PSA 9 sale prices against the raw card, the gem rate, and the expected value after fees.